Trauma, whether it be from a singular event or repeated incidences, can have profound impacts on the brain and body. This is especially true when the brain develops around the trauma, such as in cases of childhood abuse and/or neglect. However, even in adulthood, significantly stressful/traumatic events can change both the function and structure of the brain. In fact, high amounts of a stress hormone called cortisol can actually kill neurons in the brain, particularly the hippocampus (responsible for learning and memory) and prefrontal cortex (responsible for higher-level thinking, planning, emotional regulation, and behavioral inhibition.
In some cases, the individual may develop Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD), which involves an array of symptoms such as hypervigilance, sensory sensitivity, difficulty relaxing, sleep concerns, and relational problems. However, excessive stress/trauma can affect our brains even without PTSD symptoms and can manifest in a wide variety of symptoms, challenges, and diagnoses.
Here at Peak Performance Institute, we work with a wide variety of individuals who have endured traumatic experiences, including military members and veterans, first responders (e.g., firefighters), rape and domestic violence survivors, and survivors of childhood physical, sexual, and emotional abuse and neglect.
GETTING TO THE ROOTS
For those with PTSD, there’s an over-arousal of the limbic system and sympathetic nervous system. These two systems are largely involved in the body’s fight-flight-freeze response to fearful stimuli. However, with PTSD, this response is triggered even when no present danger exists. Two key structures of the limbic system responsible for this are the amygdala, the region that helps us to process emotions, and the hippocampus, which is involved in memory processing and consolidation.
Brain imaging of those with trauma histories often show increased activity within the amygdala (related to emotions) and a smaller hippocampus (related to learning and memory). While an individual with PTSD may be able to rationally recognize they aren’t in danger, the emotional, fear-based areas of the brain are essentially over-powering the more logical, thinking areas. When the sympathetic nervous system is activated, it initiates physiological responses commonly associated with PTSD, like faster heart rate, sweating, and shallow breathing.
WHAT WE CAN DO
-
- Sensors are placed on the scalp to measure brainwave activity.
- The patient receives audio and visual feedback, such as changes in a movie or video game, that reflect their brainwave patterns.
- This provides the brain with the information it needs to self-correct and form healthier, more balanced patterns.
- This process can help shift a patient from a hyper-aroused (“fight-or-flight”) state to a calmer one.
- Key types for PTSD:
- Alpha-theta training: Guides the patient into a relaxed, meditative state to process traumatic memories at a deeper, subconscious level.
- Infra-low frequency (ILF) training: Focuses on the slowest brainwaves to stabilize the nervous system and reduce hyperarousal.
- How it works:
- A therapist guides the patient through an eight-phase treatment, recalling the traumatic event in small doses.
- Simultaneously, the patient engages in bilateral stimulation, such as guided eye movements, alternating tones, or tapping.
- This process is believed to help the brain make new associations and process the “stuck” traumatic memory.
- As the memory is reprocessed, its painful intensity subsides, allowing the individual to form a more neutral memory of the event.
- EMDR and neurofeedback together:
- Combining these therapies can provide a synergistic effect. Neurofeedback helps regulate the nervous system from the “bottom-up” (at the brain level), while EMDR is a “top-down” approach that reprocesses psychological material.
- This can help prepare a patient for the intense memory reprocessing involved in EMDR by ensuring they stay within their “window of tolerance”.
- Cognitive Processing Therapy (CPT): Teaches individuals to evaluate and change the upsetting beliefs and thoughts that developed after a traumatic event.
- Prolonged Exposure (PE): Involves gradually and safely facing trauma-related memories, feelings, and situations that have been avoided since the trauma. This helps decrease PTSD symptoms by confronting the source of distress.
- Written Exposure Therapy (WET): An alternative where patients write about their traumatic experience over five sessions, which can lead to similar results as other trauma-focused therapies.
- Somatic Experiencing (SE): A body-oriented approach developed by Dr. Peter Levine that focuses on restoring the body’s natural ability to regulate itself after a traumatic event.
- Techniques include: Titration (revisiting trauma in small, manageable doses), pendulation (moving between states of arousal and calm), and grounding exercises.
- Sensorimotor Psychotherapy: Integrates sensory and motor aspects of experience into traditional talk therapy.
- Other somatic techniques:
- Breathwork: Uses specific breathing exercises to regulate the nervous system and calm the body’s stress response.
- Movement therapy: Uses physical movement to release stored tension and emotions, improving body awareness and control.
- Grounding: Simple techniques, like focusing on the sensation of your feet on the ground, that help an individual stay present and manage feelings of overwhelm or dissociation.
- Bilateral Tapping: Tapping, or Emotional Freedom Techniques (EFT), is a practice that involves tapping on acupressure points on the face and body while focusing on a stressful memory or feeling, which helps calm the nervous system and reduce distress associated with PTSD. The technique combines elements of acupuncture, acupressure, and self-help to send soothing signals to the brain, which can lower stress hormones and alleviate symptoms like anxiety and panic attacks. While considered complementary to other therapies such as CBT and EMDR, it is a self-applicable tool that can provide rapid relief during emotional activation.
WHAT THE RESEARCH SAYS
- Mechanism: EMDR helps the brain reprocess traumatic events so they no longer trigger an intense, negative emotional response. This moves the memory from an unprocessed, “stuck” state to a resolved one.
- Research findings: Multiple meta-analyses and systematic reviews have confirmed EMDR’s efficacy in reducing PTSD symptoms, depression, and anxiety. Some studies even indicate that a high percentage of patients no longer meet the criteria for a PTSD diagnosis after a small number of sessions.
- Mechanism: PTSD can cause brain dysregulation, leading to symptoms like hypervigilance, insomnia, and anxiety. Neurofeedback helps train the brain to produce healthier, more balanced brainwave patterns, which can lead to better emotional regulation and improved sleep.
- Research findings:
- A 2023 meta-analysis found that EEG-based neurofeedback had a significant effect on PTSD symptom reduction compared to control groups.
- Specific protocols, such as Alpha-Theta neurofeedback, can help create a relaxed state that is conducive to trauma processing.
- Studies on veterans have shown significant symptom reduction after a course of neurofeedback training.
- Function: Within an EMDR framework, tapping serves the same purpose as eye movements or auditory tones. It is a dual-attention stimulus that helps the brain reprocess a traumatic memory while staying grounded in the present moment.
- Specific modality: Another form, Emotional Freedom Techniques (EFT), uses tapping on specific acupressure points while a person focuses on a distressing memory. While some research supports EFT for anxiety and PTSD, it is generally considered a complementary therapy rather than a primary treatment.
- Neurofeedback first: A common strategy is to use neurofeedback first to regulate the client’s nervous system. This helps bring them into a “window of tolerance,” a state where they are calm enough to engage in deeper trauma processing without being overwhelmed.
- Enhanced EMDR effectiveness: Once the nervous system is calmer, the client is better able to process traumatic memories using EMDR. Some research indicates this combination can reduce the total number of EMDR sessions needed for a patient to feel better.
- A “game-changer” for complex cases: This integrative approach is particularly promising for patients with complex PTSD who have not responded to single-modality treatments. It addresses healing from both a “bottom-up” (neurophysiological) and a “top-down” (psychological) perspective.
- Case study examples: Case studies have documented significant symptom improvement in individuals with complex PTSD and dissociative disorders after combining neurofeedback and EMDR.
- Growing evidence base: Research supporting combined neurofeedback and EMDR is building, but further rigorous, large-scale studies are still needed to establish standardized protocols.
- Importance of clinical expertise: The success of this integrative approach is heavily dependent on the skill and experience of the clinician. A therapist trained in both modalities can tailor the treatment to the individual’s unique needs and history.
- Tapping mechanisms: While tapping is a core component of EMDR, more research is needed to differentiate the effects of tapping-based therapies like EFT from those of standard EMDR.